Bear in mind that where I live (not Europe or North America) it’s pretty difficult to try and get these kind of headphones so in my next trip to the US I plan to buy 3 different kind of headphones within the 200-700 price range each (though only one can be above 350). My initial idea was to buy very contrasting headphones so they could fulfill different needs. However, since I’m struggling so much to decide I could buy only one ridiculously expensive headphone instead if it’s really worth it.
What are my needs?
1- I want to have “great sounding” headphones for listening sessions at night in a quiet room. These sessions could get quite long sometimes (though I’d say 3 hours at most), so comfort is important.
2- I don’t plan to work or mix music with these, so I’m not lookig for very analytical headphones (that’s why I’m not considering the DT 1990). I just want to enjoy music.
3- Headphones MUST be very good / excellent at delivering the sound of “a classical / acoustic guitar + vocals”. A good part of my favorite music is just that. For example: Nick Drake, Elliott Smith, Leonard Cohen, Joanna Newsom (yes, she doesn’t play guitar but it’s almost the same), Sibylle Baier, Johnny Cash, The Tallest Man on Earth and the list goes on.
4- Other genres that I listen to are alternative rock and “indie” music (indie-rock, indie-folk, indie-pop, folk-rock), post-rock (I’m curious how headphones with great soundtage make bands like Sigur Ros sound) and dream pop (again, I’d like to have headphones with great vocals just to listen to Mazzy Star’s voice). Then I could listen to pretty much everything, depending on the day. For example, right now I’m listening to some trip-hop and ambient music, though they aren’t my favorite genres ever.
5- I don’t listen to (overly) commercial music. I don’t like much EDM, hip hop, rap, “commercial pop” (if it makes any sense), or heavy metal.
6- A big part of the music I listen to was recorded during the years 1960-2000.
7- I only own the Sony Xm3 right now. They are quite terrible for the music that I listen to, but the ANC and LDAC are great.
These are the options I’m considering right now:
HEADPHONE #1. ARGON MK3. Well, every reviewer and every owner seems to love them so I haven’t had much doubts about these headphones so far. They could be my choice for a bassy closed back headphone that’s also great for casual immersive gaming and movies. Since they are power hungry, I’m going to get the Emotiva Basx A-100, which will also be the amp for all my headphones (I cannot spend more money on a second amp). I’m aware that the Argon Mk3 may not be the best headphone for my specific needs, but I think they could perform very well where the other two don’t. Being a closed back, I won’t bother anyone and I won’t hear the fans of my computer. In other words: since I’m getting these, the other two headphones don’t have to have an outstanding bass response and I don’t care if they are good for gaming/movies. They are also unique because of having good soundstage despite being a bassy closed-back headphone.
HEADPHONE #2. SENNHEISER HD 6xx (OR SUNDARA).The 6xx may be my first choice. The price is great, everyone loves them and they seem to be perfect for my needs (comfortable, not fatiguing, could wear them for hours without much trouble and apparently they’re great for acoustic music, strings and vocals because of their mids). However, : 1) my initial idea was to buy one planar (though I could give up this idea if it isn’t worth it) and I may get the focal Elex (which also isn’t a planar) as my third headphone; 2) The Focal Elex is advertised as “the super hd 650” and while I know some people don’t agree with that statement there must be a reason for it and I noticed that the frequency response in the mids is fairly similar. In other words: Is the 6xx worth it if I also buy the Focal Elex?; 3) For the last few years, famous reviewers have at least implied that the Sundara is “better”. I take this with a grain of salt and I’m worried that the Sundara may be very analytical for me and not cater to my needs as well as the 6xx.
HEADPHONE #3. FOCAL ELEX OR HIFIMAN ANANDA. This has been an extremely tough choice for me. At first I really wanted the Ananda. But the more I do research on them the more unsure I am. Reviewers are quite divisive about them: some absolutely adore them and others say there are better options and don’t even consider them in tier lists. Even among people that liked them (including the reviewers that adored them) they usually complain about the dynamics. Others say they’re lifeless, boring, cold, with good frequency response but lacking musicality. I’m not sure how well they perform for my musical tastes. I’ve noticed there aren’t many headphones in the 500-800 price range. The Elex, on the other hand, are great according to 99,99% of reviewers but they could get very loud or harsh because of its dynamics: I wouldn’t like turning down the volume a lot because of drums hitting too hard. Both are a bit bright, so they could compliment great with the 6xx and the mk3. I just don’t know, there aren’t many comparison between these two online.
What do you think of my choices? What do you think it would be best for me? Should I get one expensive headphone instead? Do you recommend any other headphones? I know very few headphones in the 500-800 price range to be honest.