šŸ”¶ Hifiman Edition XS

Hmmm same here. I stopped looking ever-since these, myself. Just satisfied, and I can finally focus more on music rather than gear.

Kind of surprised you like them more than STAX - never tried those personally. But I stay away cuz of modding/tuning impossibilities and the TCO (Total Cost of Ownership) of electrostats. Also, I almost always hear estats have meh/thin bass.

Anyhow, good to know!

1 Like

yeah, i agree. these need no modding. I have nothing else to say!
just loving the music again.

4 Likes

Yes that’s right. But I will do a pad swap with leather pads. As good as the stock pads are the made, they seem thicker than they should be, and get itchy, there’s a play with facial hair.

I ordered from Lazada as well for US$460 together with my Topping L30 for US$108, estimated arrival is this week/ next week. Can’t wait to try them out.

yeah i have the L50 and E50 and it sounds great. i prefer it over my little dot 1+

1 Like

I have both the DT 1990 (I use A-pads) and Edition XS.
I’ve only had the XS for a day but these are my initial thoughts:

The biggest difference I’m noticing is that the XS sounds way more open than the 1990. It lets a lot more sound in and out.

The 1990 has substantially more bass, but the XS’s bass is faster and more responsive (seems like planars at work here). I miss the rumble from the 1990s but ultimately I prefer the XS here because of how clear the bass sounds.

The mids feel a little recessed on the XS but once I EQ’d them up a little they sounded fine.

The treble on the XS is quite strong. I’m happy with it, but I personally like the 1990’s treble a bit more.

In terms of comfort I prefer the XS because of the ovular earcup shape, though I wish it had a little bit more clamping force like the 1990.

I’d have to say the XS is an upgrade over the 1990 for its spacious sound and that planar bass.

4 Likes

Thank you for such detailed comparison! Looks like 1990 still looks nice in comparison:)) i will share my impression and comparison to 1990 with a pads next month, i hope so.

Sounds like recessed mids and less bass could be a problem to me, in this case 1990 will be endgame:))

1 Like

So the treble is more intense than on the 1990? Which pads did you use on the 1990?

Thanks for the review dude.
I’m planning to use these mostly for EDM so you’ve put my mind to rest.

To anyone,
Regarding the cable port size on the cups, are they 3.5mm like the Sundara’s? Just want to make sure I order the right type.
Planning on getting 3.5 dual (from cups) to 4.4 (to DAC) from ATK’s link

1 Like

Yes, the EDXS and Sundara use the same 3.5mm connection on the cup end.

2 Likes

I use A-pads.

Both headphones are definitely treble-forward, but it seems like the XS’ treble stands out more because there isn’t as much bass on it as there is on the 1990.

gzbaga on headfi just measured his pair. looks basically just like i thought it would.


and vs ananda:

6 Likes

there’s more bass on the XS than the 1990 with a pads.

Thanks for sharing the graphs! By the way, in that thread, I read that you recommend an amp that could feed them at least 2w. I was thinking about the Topping A50s, but in that same thread you discourage it for being harsh. Any chance you know anything about the Aoshida Dilvpoetry DAC DT-1? I watched a review on YouTube and got a little intrigued… it provides 2w on the balanced end and it has tubes, which seems a good fit for the EDXS.

i think the a50 would be fine. i was saying topping amps on certain headphones can be harsh but i’ve tried my XS on my a90 and it sounds great. doesn’t make it sibilant at all to me personally. i haven’t heard of the DT-1 but if aoshida is willing to put their name on it i’m sure its fine. cheaper tube amps tend to be pretty noisy but i cant say for sure how that one will be and the fact that it has tubes means you can change the sound a bit with tube rolling which could be nice. i don’t know for sure, but dilvpoetry has always been one of those companies that i suspect are rebrands of other stuff like douk audio or nobsound and i even want to throw aiyima in there but i’m unsure of that one. but like i said if aoshida is willing to put their name on it, it’s probably not bad, though i’d go insane without a manual volume knob.

1 Like

Getting very curious about this can… hearing alot of really strong reviews wondering if I should check it out

2 Likes

if you’re too on the fence i’ll send you my pair. they’re not in perfect shape because i tested what solvents i could use to remove the paint (thinking about painting them or hydrodipping them) but it’s just one tiny spot on the cup. also don’t have the stock pads anymore either cause i stole the adapter ring for the custom pads out of them lol so they’re probably not the best baseline lol.

I appreciate it but since it’s not stock(pads) sound it wouldn’t be the best trial for them otherwise I’d definitely take you up on that. The signatures frequency is in line with my preference too… has me curious as it could lead to selling my arya

Thank you very much for clarifying about the Topping and the comments on the DT-1. I also hate the fact it has no knob and personally dislike the exterior design, but if it pairs well… I will do a little bit more research, thank you.

i haven’t heard the stealth aryas but i’m guessing they’re a lot more similar to these tuning and timbre wise, but the XS is to me a lot more well rounded than the v2 arya and the timbre is leaps better than the tinny sound the arya has. gun to my head, i’d choose the XS over the arya, personally.

1 Like