Today, I posted this short reveiw on Headfi.
If interested, There is a bit of discussion going on there, since the review and before it as well.
Here it isā¦
Hifiman Edition XS Mini Review. : 11-03-2021
Box : Typical Hifiman, has the dark lush soft packing.
Cable : Decent. Rubber. Short. Mild Jank
Headband : The Original Edition X and V2 have a superior headband. The XS headband is softly padded but singular. Just a bar, typical of the older Hifiman frames. Comfort of the headband is : 7.9
Pads and Clamp. : The clamp force is going to be moderate on medium heads and slightly firm on big heads. The Pads are ok, not quite soft at first feel, but this will change with break in time
How do they sound right out of the box?
Typical of Hifman, they have a somewhat airy treble, a very slight āVā shape, and credible bass and plenty of treble extension.
Not a warm or cold sounding headphone, but other then the Susvara, the HE1000 series is more clinical and analyticalā¦= And so is the XS.
Hifiman Headphones, from HE1000 - Susvara, have a slight V shape and are slightly Treble oriented in Sound.
Less so with the Susvara.
As compared to the original āEditionā series", right out of the box, and not burned in it at all, I would consider the XS to sound more like the original Edition X, yet more controlled, FR balanced, and slightly more tonally smooth.
1.) Comfort: The headphones are comfortable, but not as comfy as the HE1000 series.
2.) Treble : Its slightly airy, and very typical of the HE 1000 series, but not quite as hyper extended as you find with the V2 and the HEKSE. Right out of the Box = There is PLENTY of Treble in the XS FR that manifests as extremely clean sound.
3.) Midrange : Hifiman does not design Audeze midrange into their headphones, and so, you wont find that type of āhonkā inside the sound of the XS. Mids presented by the XS are very articulate, pleasant, not dry, and very slightly clinical. Vocals stand out, acoustic instruments sound truthful and cymbals are very nicely presented.
Electronic music plays well in the XSās.
4.) Bass : Bass is similar to the Edition X series in tone and layering, but its a bit more controlled in that offers enough power and extension to work well with music that requires it to provide some meat, but its not a Bass Head slamming low end, its more finessed and articulate and balanced.
5.) Soundstage : You are not totally submerged inside a huge room as you find with the V2, yet, its a nicely immersive SS. The height of the SS is good, the depth is good, and the width is not disappointing, but not so wide that you lose the sense of instruments and vocals in front of you. The SS is perceived as āaccurateā vs āenhancedā.
6.) Timbre : Clean and Precise.
7.) Detail Retrieval : Here is where the XS shines brightest. Its a detailed headphone sound that manages to walk the fine line between being quite detail revealing yet still very musical. This is what Hifiman does so wellā¦ They donāt give you that over-cookes lower mid situation that fights the clarity of the treble. Vocals pop in the XSās with a lot of layering. It very impressive.
8.) Instrument Separation : Its very good like all Hifimanās.
9.) Power requirements : These are not going to sound their best out of a cell phone or weak Dac/Amp. They do bloom with Tubes and they do shine sonically their soundstage best best when used with Balanced cables and a little bit of power feeding them.
If you only uses them in SE mode, then the Vocals and the center of the soundstage is more focused and in front.
Final Analysis : A good value. Fans of the Hifiman sound will find much to enjoy. The XS offers what Hifiman does bestā¦the clarity, the details, the soundstage, the treble, and the unique overall sonic presentation that you can only get with a Hifiman Gear.
The XS is designed for listening enjoyment and offers fine detail retrieval and clarity.
