Its like the old saying “either he is dumb or incompetent”.
With that I mean, either his hearing is off or he is not bright enough to see something must be wrong, if he ends up with the iPhone sounding better than the SMSL SP200.
Either way, he is not to be trusted.
He just seems against amps and dacs as a whole lol
lol really?
Well definitely not a true believer!!
There’s no point, the test was flawed from the beginning lol, I can just go out and do the test myself anyway lol, and I will pass it with the right gear (if I’m familiar with it anyway)
Heh.
To clarify: he knows his stuff when it comes to frequency response, and can tell the difference between good and bad dynamics. But that’s about it. Detail/resolution, imaging, transient speed, impact, most of the finer points of listening to higher-end headphones still elude him, so it’s not surprising he also can’t hear the benefits of better source devices.
I would say native AAC sounds better to me than regular aptx, so I can kinda understand where he is coming from there (even then though I wouldn’t disregard aptx), but the amp and dac don’t matter thing is just ludicrous to me
IMHO there was something wrong with the SP200/SU-8 combo.
My guess was:
(Huh, spoiler alert, here are the results)
iPhone with crappy cymbals makes sense, ES100 with muddy bass makes sense, DX7 pro full clarity makes sense, but the SU-8/SP200 combo made no sense – it sounded worse than the iPhone to my ears too. 2x people thought DX7 Pro was the best. Despite all he says about “you don’t need dac/amps”, most people thought iPhone was the worst… the problem is, SU-8/SP200 combo is the second worst.
Since I haven’t watched that video, what were the final thoughts then from oluv? If the iPhone came out last what did he have to say about the other amps?
Not much. He said 40% got it wrong, and it was a waste of money for “all us old dudes”. He did not say the SP200 was crap or whatever. But there’s a left/right volume panning problem with 2 of the SP200 he received.
Some points that caught my attention that he mentions are, amps should never make any kind of difference in sound except for power and therefore more volume, But then he also mentions that he admits hearing less bass when using the iphone. seems to me like he just has a grudge.
It’s true in theory that amps should only increase volume without affecting sound, but in practice a good amp will make a difference will positively increase the sound. It’s just the I guess unfortunate to him truth lol
Which doesnt surprise me because who knows the kind of quality control a chinese company like smsl has, if any. Theres a reason why that amp is so much cheaper than the other amps with the same exact tech, for example.
Exactly. Theory and reality can be very different things just like in engineering school when there was always 2 examples for everything, the in theory one and the real one.
It’s the same way for measurement hounds, the best measurements does not mean the best sound in the end lol
He said amps were useless for him, he just prefers the simplicity. But he also said “go ahead” if you prefer amps. Shrugs. I don’t consider him as an “anti-audiophile”.
It’s a typical Objectivist view point, and wrong.
Measurements describe sounds and anything that measures adequately must sound the same as anything that measures similarly.
One of the guys over at SBAF did blind listening tests on the Magni 3 and Magni Heresy and he guessed correctly 100% of the time which was which, and as Amir points out in his review nothing in the measurements indicates they should sound different.
His comments are pretty anti-audiophile, and somewhat attacks those that don’t agree with him
I will admit with the SP200, that volume thing he presented does exist, but how he presents it is exaggerated. He had to have done some manipulation or skewed the presentation where it corrects itself at around 12 oclock or so. I would say it happens closer around 7 when it is nearly muted, but I never considered it an issue.
Well he said the iPhone was better than the SP200, but… I believe him. There was something wrong with his SU-8 or something. I don’t believe the SP200 is crap, just… I believe something was wrong with his stuff.
He will use the DX7 Pro now, and may get the THX 789.
