tldr, I do not like the direction the mechanical keyboard community has taken, linear and tactile switches have stagnated with all that has been done is change materials and the speed bump on mx brown. Also its just copium and a skill issue trying to do all these mods to a keyboard to make it sound muted when if it was a good switch in the first place you would not do that.
I do not get the direction the whole mechanical keyboard community has gone toward, call me old school or something but I do not get the whole trend of switches. I got back into the hobby again cause I wanted a new board that was potentially quieter than the board I have currently and one that was more ergonomic.
So far I got a linear board and a clicky one. For a linear board I got some gateron optical switches and for my other one I am rocking an ibm model m. I thought that since I been out of this hobby for like 5 years things would change with old switches getting remakes so they can fit mx keycaps but the community just seems to want to rehash the same products over and over again. With switch materials, there is only so much that they can do to try and reduce friction to improve “switch feel”. You will always run into the friction from the contact leaf if you try and pursue the cherry style, something like optical keyswitches do not have the contact leaf so they can be a whole lot smoother than traditional ones. Yes, optical switches need a special pcb to work, but its not like the majority of the people in the hobby are hand wiring switches, they are just taking a board off amazon or some other retail site and plop some switches and keycaps onto it, not really that customizable in my opinion but I guess its different than just buying “gaming” ones.
Now onto tactile switches the main thing that made me not want to lurk. I am gonna just say it outfront that I do not like mx style tactility its just a lazy bump in it and these new switches I got confirm it. I bought basically 3 switches, feker holy pandas, anubis switches from cannonkeys, and some tecsee sapphires thinking that maybe since they have difference springs, bumps and material it would create a tactile event that I might enjoy but no they all are not really that good and feel somewhat similar enough to me that I do not care. I know the dangers of hype stuff but thought that maybe since there was new stuff like the box switches and all that things would change. These holy panda switches that were hyped up are not round and honestly not that impressive, if you want a round tactility just stick to a regular membrane board or a topre one, you could get a cheapish electro capacitive one for around 100 bucks from akko online. The anubis switches feel as though you are driving on in Camden, New Jersey, bumpy in an unrefined way while having a slow return as though you were stuck in a one way alley although thank goodness this time it does not have some crazed lunatic waving around a chainsaw. The tecsees are just meh, not really tactile, the bump is just I guess there in my opinion. It just upsets me that after all these years we basically only got a switches that are slight alterations of a speed bump. There are so many different ways that tactility could be achieved and yet none were adapted. The only new thing is like the zeal switches but those are just insanely priced and are hella unrefined.
Also sound, honestly its just a skill issue and that people just really dont like the sound that their switches make. Cherry stabs are cheap for genuine ones and can be made easily to perform well. It takes some work but since most people are taking their stabs apart anyway to mod them, cherry stabs end up fine and on par with a lot of the more expensive options. All the people are putting like tons of foam, silicon, and all that to dampen their keyboard to make it sound good, in my opinion its just copium. You are trying to mute your switches because they sound bad, just make or get switches that sound better and maybe people dont have to wreck a whole case or put tons of foam in to try and make it sound “good”. I know a lot of stuff is subjective and preference but honestly I find the modern enthusiast keyboard sound to be extremely too muted and somehow hollow sounding. If I were to go and have enough money and skill I would really make tooling just to have some type of ergonomic keyboard with some buckling springs or something but I definitely don’t have the money to do that.