đŸ”· Schiit Asgard 3

Hi! Welcome to HFGF!

@Bmn1251’s advice is solid. I’ll also steer you toward the Schiit stack. I think the Asgard in particular will also be a better sonic match to your 6xx and Sundara. But, TBH, you can’t really make a bad decision here. I just think the Schiit stack leaves more options on the table for you down the road.

2 Likes

Does the Schiit Stack sound much different from the Element?
Sorry, I am very new to this whole Audiophile world
 I read someplaces if you have a good amp it “shouldn’t sound different or color the sound” but then I also see comments about how some headphones (in this example, HD6xx & Sundara) are a better match for something like the A3.
Really just asking for my own edification because I’d love to gain a deeper knowledge of how this all works.

1 Like

Thanks! I think I leaning towards the Schiit Stack at this point
 I do have 1 final question about the A3 and then I am done bothering you all haha:
I have seen some comments about temperature of the Asgard when it is running for a while
 I live in pretty warm area where it can sometimes get to 80 degrees Fahrenheit in my apartment during the summer months. Would this be a concern if the Asgard runs hot on its own?

1 Like

I know you replied to @Bmn1251 but I’ll jump in here because I’m smarter, better looking, and more humble ( :laughing:).

No need to apologize. We were all new once!

That statement gets thrown around a lot but is quite misleading, IMO. As a theoretical target, an amp/dac/speaker/headphone/audio component shouldn’t change the sound from what it sounds like in real life. The brutal truth is there is no audio system that can reproduce that in existence right now no matter how much you spend. What appears to have happened is that many manufactureres, especially with amps and dacs, are chasing measurement excellence: vanishingly low THD numbers, ‘flat’ frequency response, etc. In reality, solid state amps and most dacs surpassed the levels of measurements that are relevant to human hearing years ago. Now many are just one-upping each other instead of worrying about how good it sounds. That’s a long-winded way of saying that you simply won’t find an amp that does NOT color the sound from reality. It’s also important to realize that even if 2 amps have virtually identical frequency response and distortion measurements they can sound quite different from each other. My direct response to your question then is, as you get further into the hobby, pay attention to what you enjoy over chasing measurements.

Yes. Some amp-and-headphone pairs (and amp-and-dac pairs, etc) do get along with each other better than other pairs. We call how well they get along “synergy.” IMO it’s true that the A3 will likely synergize better with Sundara and 6xx than the Element, although they’ll both sound quite good. I own Asgard and 6xx and also the JDS Labs Atom which uses similar tech to Element. The Asgard responds better to the 6xx’s increased impedance in the bass and treble, ramping up its power output in those frequencies so that the 6xx sounds a little more full and extended than on the Atom/Element tech. Likewise the Asgard’s slight warm tuning and smooth treble should make a good match for the Sundara’s neutral-bright signature.

It is fun! I’m still learning! This forum has really knowledgeable people so feel free to ask all the questions you need.

No. The Asgard is designed to run quite hot. As long as you can properly ventilate its top panel you should be fine.

6 Likes

Just one you got wrong “better looking” :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

1 Like

You keep telling yourself that :grin:

1 Like

@CoolHindude but for real though, everything @WaveTheory has said(about the a3) is great :+1:

3 Likes

Throwing my 2 cents in here as I owned the El Stack 1 a while back. The EL Amp probably is one of a small few that can compete with a Schiit Asgard 3. I very slightly prefer the Asgard 3, but when you are talking price to performance, the Asgard 3 far surpasses the EL Amp, IMO.

4 Likes

@WaveTheory @Bmn1251 @Hazi59 Thanks for all of your input! I think I have made my decision to go for Schiit! Seems like the general consensus that I should just get the Modius over the Modi 3+, Modi 3 MB, or of the DAC options for the A3
 Is that about right?

3 Likes

You’re welcome!

I had a Modi 3 (not the 3+) and it wasn’t quite to the standard Schiit has set at other price points. I haven’t heard Modi MB, either. I will say though that the Modius is the overall best-sounding <$200 dac I’ve heard. It also comes with the option of scaling up to balanced amps sometime in the future. Plus, the Unison USB is really nice in that even if you switch inputs, the USB never disconnects from the computer. I find that handy. I run audio connections both from my motherboard’s optical output and USB. I use the USB for music apps that have an exclusive mode and set the optical out as the default audio device for Windows mixer. With Unison, I can play something through USB + exclusive mode, switch to web browser and hear a youtube video through the optical output by just selecting inputs on the dac. Otherwise you have to stop the music app, disable exclusive mode, watch the video, go back to music app, start exclusive mode
it gets complex.

5 Likes

Jeez, I am going down the rabbit hole faster than Michael Jordan went down that hole in Space Jam


What is your reason for using 2 different output off of the same motherboard? I was planning on using USB but I just realized that my PC does have an optical output as well.

Let me put a quick 2 cents here as I own a JDS Labs Element 2. Sound-wise, I think it will do just as fine as the A3, but probably sound different, as @WaveTheory have already explained in his post. As for pairing, I would say that both DMS and Zeos have praised the pairing of the Sennheiser 600 series with the Element, so I’m not so sure it’s a clear win for Schiit.

Also, I would say if you want to minimize desk space, Element is the way to go. Aside from an, IMO, somewhat oversized power brick, this thing is small. It’s almost the size of my hand and yet delivers some nice and clean power.

As for heat, it does run from warm to hot depending on gain and your temperature. Now I live in Brazil and we stay between 25ÂșC and 30ÂșC for around 6 months a year, but I’ve experienced hotter things with Class A designs, so I think you should be fine.

But again, I don’t think you can go wrong either way, so
 have fun and enjoy the ride down the hole. :joy:

3 Likes

Lol. That’s an old-school reference.

Exclusive mode bypasses Windows’ software audio mixer. If you have multiple apps running that can all produce sound the mixer does what its name implies, mixes all the sounds together into one audio signal. This mixing often requires changing bit rates or sampling rates and adds more layers of processing to the signal. That added processing can degrade overall audio quality. Music apps with exclusive mode bypass that audio mixer and send that audio signal direct to the dac without changing it (usually, if it’s a good exclusive out - which most are - unless you’re using AmazonHD, which isn’t - there are rabbitholes upon rabbitholes here). Games often engage an exclusive mode too so you don’t get interupted by message notifications or the like while playing. Exclusive modes mute any other apps that aren’t the one engaged in the exclusive mode. If you were playing music through Foobar2K for example in exclusive mode, you couldn’t hear a youtube video in your browser. In fact, you may have to restart your web browser to re-engage its audio entirely if you launched the browser while Foobar had exclusive mode engaged. All that is a pain to manage. The approach I mentioned above was my way around that issue and makes managing multiple apps with sound easier while still giving me the option of an unaltered music audio signal.

Since you will probably ask, the difference in audio quality between the Windows mixer and exclusive mode isn’t huge for most material. Windows’s mixer is actually pretty good. However, with a lossless file of a high quality recording played back on quality audio gear, you can start to hear the benefits of exclusive mode.

4 Likes

@WaveTheory This has been a very productive work day and I have learned a lot :wink:

Starting out, I think I would probably only use 1 input. I usually am just listening to music as I browse the internet. If not, I am listening to music when I am on discord and gaming with my friends and it sounds like using multiple inputs and exclusive mode my mess with my ability to hear some tunes as I chat/game
 That is, unless I completely misunderstood what you were explaining to me.

After these conversations today, I am going to have to make a Pros/Cons list for the Schiit Stack and the Element 2 to decide because of my Type A personality lol

2 Likes

@WaveTheory Very solid, helpful info from you in all these recent posts. Thanks to ALL who contributed.

2 Likes

New member here. Just ordered an Asgard 3 with True Multibit DAC. I had the original Jot and sold it as it didn’t seem as good, to my ears, as my old standby PS Audio GHCA amp and Musical Fidelity M1 DAC combo. I hope the Asgard fares better with my HD-650, B&W P9, and Audeze LCD2.

Unfortunately shipping is delayed. In the meantime I catch up on the many threads on these forums.

6 Likes

:ok_hand:

2 Likes

Welcome to the forum.
I don’t have the MB module, but I can say the A3 is fantastic.
Mine does fantastic with my Aeon RT, HE-560, DT880(600ohm), HD58X, MadDogs, personally modified Fostex t40rp mkIII. The amp has plenty of power and a great sound with wide soundstage.

2 Likes

Newbie alert. Got here from a Z review. I just ordered the Asgard as my first amp. I have a Nad HP50, One More Trident, and a week ago I got the M570 as my first Planar. I was enjoying the Zen Dac for 6 weeks, then it just started making white noise for no reason. Found this thread and all the love for the Asgard. I am going to restart with a good amp. Hopefully ifi will replace my Zen Dac under warranty. They have been very slow to response. What sound improvement should I expect for the A3 and Zen combo?

2 Likes

Newest member of the family, being fed by the Bifrost 2

16 Likes